ryan kelly before green background

Endless streams of polished content. Generated at lightning speed. Without adding to your headcount. 

What’s not to love?

At first, AI was giving your content marketing team an edge. But then every other marketing team started using it, too.

Now, with so much content looking and sounding the same, it’s harder than ever for brands to stand out. Especially those relying on AI without the oversight of skilled writers.

So, what does this all mean for marketing leaders and their recruitment decisions as they head into 2027?

We sat down with Ryan Kelly at Creative Natives about what’s happening in the copywriting talent market – and why the best writers are becoming increasingly valuable.

Your secret weapon isn’t so secret anymore

Remember when being an early adopter of AI felt like having an unfair advantage?

Today, anyone with an internet connection can generate a half-decent article, social post, webpage or eDM. But Ryan Kelly of Creative Natives offers a word of warning.

‘Large language models create copy based on your average,’ he explains. ‘Which means you’re not getting those moments of genius. Using AI, brands will never be able to capture the unexpected creative breakthroughs that make them memorable.’

So, if your competitors are using the same tools to produce similarly polished content, where does that leave you?

Back at square one.

Your audience is getting harder to impress

Audiences are far from stupid. They’re becoming better and better at recognising AI-generated content – and increasingly discerning about what deserves their attention.

‘We’re all becoming innately sceptical and a lot more judgemental of copy,’ Ryan observes.

And who can blame us?

There’s only so much ‘In today’s fast-paced digital landscape’ a person can endure before developing a twitch.

For brands, this creates an interesting problem. Producing more content might improve your publishing frequency, but it won’t necessarily improve your chances of being noticed.

Ryan suggests a different measure of success.

‘Rather than looking at volume, look at how many genuinely interesting things your brand is putting out.’

It’s a question worth asking at your next marketing meeting.

Can you still surprise your audience?

According to Ryan, one of the most valuable weapons in a brand’s arsenal is the ability to make people feel something.

‘Those who can provoke emotions in their writing are going to be a premium,’ he says.

And that emotional response doesn’t always need to be profound. Sometimes, a perfectly pitched joke can do more for your brand than a thousand polished sentences. Ryan even floated an interesting theory about copywriters: are they just very introverted comedians?

‘People who are genuinely funny, not just people who think they are, are few and far between.’

Of course, humour isn’t appropriate for every brand or message. But the underlying skill – understanding an audience well enough to entertain or move them – is invaluable.

Don’t let AI dilute your brand voice

Imagine Apple suddenly adopting the tone of a government tax notice. Or Gucci communicating like a discount retail warehouse.

Something would feel off, wouldn’t it?

That’s because a distinctive brand voice is part of what makes a brand recognisable.

‘A brand should be investing in its tone of voice anyway; it’s core to everything,’ Ryan explains.

Yet when businesses rely on AI without clear brand guidelines or skilled copywriters overseeing the output, that distinctiveness quickly disappears. Ryan believes this is prompting smart brands to reconsider their approach.

‘We’ve reached a point where smart business leaders are saying, “Our voice is completely vanilla!”’

The solution isn’t necessarily abandoning AI. But you do need to ensure your team understands your brand well enough to use it without sacrificing your uniqueness. This means investing in brand voice development and training.

And as more brands recognise the value of distinctive, engaging content, they’re also reconsidering who they trust to create it.

The catch? The best copywriters come at a price

Despite predictions that AI would make copywriters redundant, Ryan is seeing a renewed demand for human writers.

But there’s a catch. 

‘We’re definitely seeing brands coming back to human copywriters, but those human copywriters have got to be really good.’

And that expertise comes at a price.

‘If the top 5–10% are really sought after, their rates go up because there aren’t enough of them.’

What about the talent you already have?

But before you blow your marketing budget on a copywriting superstar, consider the talent already in your organisation.

Could your existing team become better writers with the right training?

Ryan believes ongoing development is essential, particularly as AI changes the expectations placed on professional writers.

There’s also a case for encouraging writers to challenge the status quo. After all, if your team is constantly instructed to produce safe, conventional content, even the most talented writer will struggle to deliver something remarkable.

Or bring in the experts

Of course, not every business is in a financial position to hire specialist copywriters tomorrow.

Even those that can may occasionally need fresh thinking. And that presents another option: accessing specialist expertise through a copywriting agency rather than trying to develop every capability in-house.

It’s also worth considering where your internal team’s strengths lie. Are they best placed to manage day-to-day communications, while an external team handles a major website rewrite project?

Ultimately, it’s about making sure every piece of communication gets the attention and expertise it deserves.

As Ryan puts it, ‘Human brands, brands that focus on every touchpoint… they’re the ones that understand the importance of copy.’

Want to give your brand an edge? At Refresh Marketing, we help businesses develop distinctive brand voices and create content worth reading. Let’s talk.